Punch at the Young Vic Is a Knockout – Honest, Human, and Unmissable

Punch | Young Vic Theatre until 26th April

Punch grips you from its very first moments. It tells a true story of pain, hope, and change. Written by the prolific James Graham, the play offers a clear look at the possibility of redemption with a real emotional depth that never preaches and is inherently theatrical.

At its heart, Punch recounts the journey of Jacob Dunne, a man from Nottingham whose life was forever altered by a single, fateful moment. His transformation is marked not by despair but by a hard-won reform that inspires a fresh start. The wonderful company is led by David Shields, who plays Jacob – and charts his journey from a firecracker of energy to the Jacob of today who is an advocate for change and hope.

The remainder of the cast multi-role superbly and clearly delineate their characters whilst never drifting into caricature. The play also focuses on James Hodgkinson’s parents, brilliantly portrayed by Julie Hesmondhalgh and Tony Hirst. Their journey from grief – if not quite forgiveness – to a willingness to move forward and turn a terrible tragedy into something positive is the other key theme of the play. This is deeply moving and an insight into human behaviour at its best, and the fact that it is all true only heightens the emotional impact.

The play also explains the process of restorative justice – where both the perpetrator and victim of a crime are brought together. It is a slow, thoughtful, and careful process that aims to build understanding and looks after both parties. It offers a clear path forward for both sides and brings a sense of balance to an otherwise painful event. It is the kind of theatre I love – that educates, but not in a dry or laboured way.

Originally produced in Nottingham, Punch carries the weight of its roots with it, reflecting the local context from which the story emerged – a city known for its resilience and community spirit. It is a local story, but with universal appeal.

Punch uses the real-life journeys of Jacob Dunne and James Hodgkinson’s parents to show that even the most painful events can lead to meaningful change. It is a stirring reminder of how hard truths can be shared with care, humour, and sensitivity.

The rumours were that the play would skip the West End and move straight to New York – but I am delighted to learn that it has just announced a 10-week West End run at the Apollo Theatre from the 22nd September, giving more people a chance to see this significant and important production.

Anyone who values theatre that speaks honestly about life, Punch is a must-see.

Follow us on:

Subscribe to our YouTube channel for the latest videos and updates!

We value your thoughts! Share your feedback and help us make EyeOnLondon even better!