Arcadia at the Old Vic

Arcadia | Old Vic Theatre until 21 March

An ambitious but uneven revival of Stoppard’s modern classic

Some plays entertain you for an evening. Others make you feel slightly more intelligent just for sitting through them. Arcadia is very much the second category.

Written by Tom Stoppard and first staged at the National Theatre in the 1990s, it remains one of his greatest achievements. Landscape gardening. Chaos theory. Fermat’s Last Theorem. Lord Byron. Romantic longing. Academic rivalry. All in one play. It sounds daunting. It isn’t, or at least it shouldn’t be.

Stoppard does something theatrically daring here. He keeps us in one room but moves us between centuries. The same country house in Derbyshire. The early nineteenth century. The late twentieth. Characters separated by time but connected by curiosity, desire, and misunderstanding. It’s a structural masterstroke.

We watch modern academics attempt to reconstruct the past. We, meanwhile, have already seen it. We know what really happened. That dramatic irony gives the play its engine. Bernard the don builds a theory about Byron that is gloriously, confidently wrong. Hannah the historian tries to pin down truth through documents and evidence. Meanwhile, in the past, young Thomasina is discovering ideas about entropy that prefigure modern mathematics.

It’s heady stuff. But beneath the equations and cleverness lies something much simpler. It’s about love. About sexual attraction. About people consistently falling for the wrong person. Across centuries, nothing changes.

And it has a heart. The final scene is one of the most quietly devastating in modern British theatre. Stoppard lets intellect and emotion meet in the same breath. Few writers can manage that balance.

This production at the Old Vic Theatre reconfigures the space and stages the play in the round, with a revolve helping the timelines bleed into one another. It’s visually clear, costumes firmly signal which century we’re in, and the mechanics of the storytelling are easy to follow.

The challenge with Arcadia is never clarity of plot. Stoppard is generous. He makes you feel you understand, at least while you’re watching. The challenge is precision.

The language demands absolute control. The jokes, and there are many, are rhythm-based. Schoolboy gags sit right next to discussions of chaos theory. If the timing is off by a beat, the joke disappears. If the thought isn’t fully landed, the idea floats away.

On the night I attended, the performance before press night, too many of those beats were missed. Act One sparkled intermittently. Act Two, where the emotional and intellectual threads tighten together, lost some of its comic fizz. Lines that should detonate gently simply passed by. It may well settle. This is a fiendishly difficult play to calibrate.

And yet I am always glad to see Arcadia. Even when imperfectly realised, it remains a work of absolute theatrical ambition. It trusts its audience. It assumes curiosity. It asks us to lean forward rather than sit back. As Thomasina observes, we are all searching.

This revival may not fully master the play’s complexities just yet, but the play itself remains extraordinary. And that, ultimately, is why it endures. Even imperfectly realised, Arcadia remains a work of absolute theatrical ambition.

A structurally brilliant play that fuses mathematics, history and desire across two centuries. This Old Vic revival is clear and ambitious, but performances sometimes lack the precision Stoppard’s language demands. The play itself remains a modern classic.

For more theatre reviews and cultural writing, follow EyeOnLondon.

[Image Credit | Manuel Harlan]

Follow us on:

Subscribe to our YouTube channel for the latest videos and updates!

We value your thoughts! Share your feedback and help us make EyeOnLondon even better!